By Semih Idiz, Al-Monitor, June 14, 2016
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan warned of dire consequences to Turkish-German relations after the Bundestag adopted its nonbinding resolution [on June 2] recognizing the mass killing of Armenians in 1915 as genocide. Ankara says this is a historic calumny against the Turkish nation.
Turkey’s actions so far have been limited. Ankara has recalled its ambassador to Berlin and has issued a litany of counter accusations with obvious references to the Holocaust and the mass killings of the Herero people in Namibia by the German military in the early years of the 20th century.
Notwithstanding these angry remarks, Ankara has refrained from any steps that would seriously undermine Turkish-German ties. The presence of more than three million Turks in Germany and the vast economic interests Turkey has in that country clearly tie its hands.
Reports that Ankara and Berlin may have agreed on military facilities for Germany at Incirlik Air Base in southern Turkey, on the other hand, show that it is business as usual between the two countries when it comes to brass tacks issues.
Unable to respond to Berlin in any meaningful manner, a frustrated Ankara appears to be focusing the full weight of its ire on German deputies of Turkish origin who supported the Armenian resolution.
Erdogan is leading the chorus and, starting with Cem Ozdemir, the co-chairman of the Alliance 90/Green Party that co-sponsored the resolution in question, is branding them with insulting adjectives such as “treacherous Turks.” He even asked for blood samples to be taken from the deputies to prove whether or not they were Turkish.
Almost all of the deputies in question are German born and by their own accounts consider themselves as Germans, although they do not deny their Turkish lineage. Protesting to Ankara over the verbal attacks against its deputies, Berlin has also provided extra security for them against possible attacks from radical members of the German Turkish community. The deputies have also been advised not to travel to Turkey.
Norbert Lammert, the president of the Bundestag, was among those who condemned Erdogan over his remarks. “Whosoever tries to pressurize a deputy has to know he is attacking our parliament and democracy. In that case we will show every necessary reaction possible under our laws,” he said, referring to Erdogan’s remarks as “backward.”
Gunter Krings, Germany’s parliamentary state secretary at the Federal Ministry of the Interior, warned Turks living in Germany not to act on Erdogan’s remarks. “Those who think and speak [like Erdogan] will show that they have not integrated with Germany and German law. This must, of course, be taken into account in considerations about their residence permits,” Krings warned, according to the German media.
Given these exchanges, it would not appear to be the right moment for a strategic military agreement between the two countries. The German and Turkish media, however, are reporting that an agreement has been concluded in principle between Ankara and Berlin for the construction of facilities for the German air force at Incirlik Air Base at a cost of 65 million euros ($72.8 million).
Germany, which is part of the U.S.-led coalition against the Islamic State, is planning to construct a fixed location for itself inside Incirlik, with a command post, aviation area, accommodations and a maintenance facility. It already has Tornado jets and an aerial refueling jet, as well as around 200 military personnel deployed at the base.
The opposition in Turkey was quick to hit at the government over the inconsistency these reports reflected against the backdrop of the Armenian resolution.
“The German parliament has adopted a resolution. Everyone in Turkey is talking and blasting away from below the belt. Then we hear that the Incirlik base has been opened to Germany,” Kemal Kilicdaroglu, the leader of the main opposition Republican People’s Party, said.
Aware of the sensitivity regarding this issue, government spokesman Nurettin Canikli told reporters, following a June 13 Cabinet meeting, that a final decision on the topic had not been reached at yet.
“Germany made a request, but no decision has been taken yet. All our relevant organizations continue work with regard to the unfortunate resolution adopted by the German parliament,” Canikli said.
His remarks appeared to suggest that Ankara might not endorse the Incirlik agreement with Germany. A Western diplomat speaking on condition of anonymity due to his sensitive position told Al-Monitor that the project was too advanced for this to happen.
“Turkey would lose a lot of credibility among its allies,” the diplomat said. “Turkish officials are aware of the potential for serious negative fallout for Turkey such a drastic step would bring,” he added.
Retired Ambassador Ozdem Sanberk, who heads the Ankara-based International Strategic Research Organization, believes a serious lack of trust in Turkey is the root cause of the current state of affairs between Ankara and Berlin.
“Turkey’s growing introversion, its angry challenges to the world with remarks that at times amount to insults … all of this backfires in the end,” Sanberk told Al-Monitor. “The doleful state of press freedom and the independence of the judiciary, as well as other similar topics, have placed Turkey in a bad light. This is not only a problem with Germany, but also with the United States, the European Union, Great Britain, France and even Arab countries,” Sanberk said.
“Agreeing with Germany over Incirlik is the consistent thing to do, doing the opposite would be inconsistent,” Sanberk added, going on to indicate that bombastic statements, religion and ideology have no place in foreign policy.
“Every government has its own foreign policy, but if this strays away from basic principles, such as maintaining the country’s territorial integrity and security, and trying to keep pace with the contemporary and modern world, then that country ends up paying a price,” Sanberk said.
He added that it was “also crucial for a country to maintain the right balance between its aims and its capacity to fulfill these aims.”
Sanberk’s words put the basic problem Turkey has with regard to Germany after the adoption of the Armenian genocide resolution into perspective. The bottom line is that Ankara will huff and puff, but it will be business as usual in the end.
Semih Idiz is a columnist for Al-Monitor’s Turkey Pulse. He is a journalist who has been covering diplomacy and foreign policy issues for major Turkish newspapers for 30 years. His opinion pieces can be followed in the English-language Hurriyet Daily News. His articles have also been published in The Financial Times, The Times of London, Mediterranean Quarterly and Foreign Policy magazine.
Germany triggers Turkish outcry with June 2 Armenian genocide vote, Reuters, June 2, 2016
German MPs who voted to recognise Armenia ‘genocide’ given full police protection
Eleven German MPs have been placed under 24-hour police protection due their involvement in a dispute with Turkey which dates back to the First World War.
The politicians have received thousands of death threats after voting for citizens to be allowed to describe the massacre of Armenians by Ottoman Turks in 1915 as genocide. They have also been warned by Germany’s foreign ministry not to travel to Turkey, or face risking their personal security.
Last week’s vote in German parliament has created deeper tensions with Turkey, with the latter’s President Recep Erdogan reacting angrily to the decision and the country recalling its ambassador from Berlin.
One of the MPs in question, Green Party leader Cem Ozdemir, told the Local: “This genocide was waiting to be worked through. There is never a favorable time to speak about something as dreadful as genocide.”
He also confirmed he had been sent multiple messages from Turkish protesters, including some saying: “We will find you anywhere”.
In reaction to the announcement, Mr Erdogan accused the MPs of backing the “terrorism” of the Kurdistan Worker’s Party (PKK), which has campaigned to have the massacre reclassified. He continued by demanding that the MPs have “blood tests” to “see what kind of Turks they really are” as he suspected they had “impure blood”.
Armenia claims as many as 1.5 million of its people were murdered during the atrocities [in 1915], although Turkey says the number of deaths was far fewer.
Turkey argues many of the dead were killed in combat during the First World War and were not innocent people slaughtered by troops, although this account has been disputed by Germany, France and Russia.
The UK, the U.S. and most other countries are yet to adopt an official position on the matter.
EDITOR’S NOTE: We remind our readers that publication of articles on our site does not mean that we agree with what is written. Our policy is to publish anything which we consider of interest, so as to assist our readers in forming their opinions. Sometimes we even publish articles with which we totally disagree, since we believe it is important for our readers to be informed on as wide a spectrum of views as possible.