Ukrainian-born soloist dropped from TSO for her political views
By Robert Everett-Green, published in The Globe and Mail, April 6, 2015. (Updated version of article as well as additional information is further below.)
The Toronto Symphony Orchestra is getting a taste of the rough side of social media, as word quickly spreads of its decision to bar a piano soloist for her political views. The TSO decided not to put Ukrainian-born pianist Valentina Lisitsa on stage this week, citing “ongoing accusations of deeply offensive language by Ukrainian media outlets.”
That comment, from a terse statement by TSO president Jeff Melanson, apparently refers to some responses to Lisitsa’s comments on Twitter about the ongoing conflict in Ukraine. Melanson refused repeated requests to elaborate on the grounds for her dismissal.
Lisitsa broke the story of her dismissal on Monday morning in a long, impassioned note on Twitter and YouTube.
“Someone in the orchestra’s top management, likely after the pressure from a small but aggressive lobby claiming to represent the Ukrainian community, has made a decision that I should not be allowed to play,” she writes, referring to her scheduled TSO performances on Wednesday and Thursday. “I don’t even know who my accusers are, I am kept in the dark about it.”
Lisitsa also writes that the TSO, which offered to pay her entire fee for the cancelled shows, threatened her with reprisals if she were to go public about the reason. “If they do it once, they will do it again and again, until the musicians, artists are intimidated into voluntary censorship,” she writes.
Twitter quickly responded with a hashtag – #letvalentinaplay – and a barrage of tweets in her support. One came from Bravo Niagara!, which presented Lisitsa in recital in St. Catharines, Ont., on Sunday night. “In defence of freedom of speech, #letvalentinaplay,” it reads. “Music can’t be silenced!”
Lisitsa has a formidable presence on social media. One of her YouTube videos, of her performance of Beethoven’s “Moonlight” Sonatas, has over nine million views. Her present career was built in part on her tremendous Internet following. Three years ago, a Google Analytics report on her social media heft clinched her a sold-out show at the Royal Albert Hall that was streamed online by 100,000 people.
The TSO may not have realized the extent of her reach, but they’re finding out now. The orchestra’s Facebook page is flooded with messages of support for Lisitsa, along with a few more critical responses.
“As one of Canada’s most important cultural institutions,” Melanson’s statement says, “our priority must remain on being a stage for the world’s great works of music, and not for opinions that some believe to be deeply offensive.” Unfortunately for the TSO, a lot of people are finding offence in the orchestra’s attempts to remain inoffensive.
* * *
And here is a later version of the Globe and Mail article, updated late on April 6, 2015 (same weblink as above)
The Toronto Symphony Orchestra has cancelled appearances this week by Ukrainian-born piano soloist Valentina Lisitsa, apparently because of tweets she posted that were hostile to the current Ukrainian government.
A terse statement by TSO president Jeff Melanson said Ms. Lisitsa was let go over “ongoing accusations of deeply offensive language by Ukrainian media outlets.”
Mr. Melanson, who refused requests for an interview, issued his note after Ms. Lisitsa revealed the incident on Monday morning in a long, impassioned note linked to her Twitter and Facebook accounts.
“Someone in the orchestra’s top management, likely after the pressure from a small but aggressive lobby claiming to represent the Ukrainian community, has made a decision that I should not be allowed to play,” she wrote, referring to her scheduled TSO performances on Wednesday and Thursday. “I don’t even know who my accusers are, I am kept in the dark about it.”
Her Twitter statements have outraged prominent members of the Ukrainian-Canadian community, which broadly supports the current government. “Ms. Lisitsa has been engaged in a long campaign on social media belittling, insulting and disparaging the people of Ukraine as they face direct military aggression at the hands of the Russian Federation,” Paul Grod, president of the Ukrainian Canadian Congress, said in an e-mail exchange. Ms. Lisitsa did not respond to requests for an interview on Monday.
Ms. Lisitsa’s tweets about the Ukrainian regime have included some harsh comparisons with Nazi Germany, sometimes laced with morbid comedy. “In a new European Ukraine, the camps will give the subhumans [ethnic Russians] condemned to gas chambers an opportunity to offset their carbon footprint,” she says in one.
Ms. Lisitsa is an ethnic Russian who was born in Ukraine and speaks Ukrainian (she now lives in North Carolina). Her tweets are strongly supportive of the Russian minority in Ukraine, but she seems to oppose the civil war.
“The worst thing that can happen to any country is fratricidal war,” she says in her statement, “people seeing each other, their neighbours as enemies to be eliminated.”
“You might find some of [my tweets] offensive,” she says, “[but] satire and hyperbole are the best literary tools to combat the lies.”
Mr. Grod said he supports the TSO’s decision. “Most disturbing are Ms. Lisitsa’s false allegations that the government of Ukraine is ‘Nazi,’ and stating that the Government of Ukraine is setting up ‘filtration camps,’” he said. “These are only a few examples of the hateful opinions that Ms. Lisitsa has shared through her Twitter account.”
Adrian Bryttan, a writer for the Edmonton-based Ukrainian Weekly, lambasted Ms. Lisitsa in an article in December, for “anti-Ukraine hate speech.” He pointed to tweets in which she had said the country was “a society sunk beyond redemption,” and which “owned a proud and long history with Russia, threw it away and invented myths.” He ended his article by saying: “Ukrainian communities might be interested to greet Ms. Lisitsa at her upcoming concerts … with the Toronto Symphony.”
It is not clear what harm the TSO expected if Ms. Lisitsa performed. Soloists never speak from the platform unless invited to do so by the conductor. The work she was to perform, Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto No. 2, has no political subtext. Valery Gergiev, who has conducted the orchestra without incident, is a well-known supporter and confidant of Russian President Vladimir Putin. Mr. Gergiev was dropped from a Poland-themed festival concert in Germany in November, apparently after a complaint from the Polish embassy.
The TSO’s record on freedom of speech was tarnished in 1951, when six players were refused visas for a U.S. tour over alleged communist sympathies. The orchestra replaced “the Symphony Six” for the tour, and at the end of the season did not renew their contracts. Two TSO board members resigned in protest.
The Symphony Six did not have access to social media, where Ms. Lisitsa has a formidable presence. A YouTube video of her performance of Beethoven’s “Moonlight” Sonata has more than nine million views. Her career was built in part on her Internet following. Three years ago, a Google Analytics report on her social-media heft clinched her a sold-out show at London’s Royal Albert Hall that 100,000 people streamed online.
The TSO’s Facebook page was flooded on Monday with messages of support for Ms. Lisitsa and a few more critical responses. Twitter responded with a hashtag – #letvalentinaplay – and a barrage of tweets in her support. One came from Bravo Niagara!, which presented Ms. Lisitsa in recital in St. Catharines, Ont., on Sunday night. “In defence of freedom of speech, #letvalentinaplay,” it reads. “Music can’t be silenced!”
Some in her corner argue for no more than her right to offend without being punished professionally.
Ms. Lisitsa wrote that the TSO, which offered to pay her entire fee for the cancelled shows, threatened reprisals if she went public about the reason. “If they do it once, they will do it again and again, until the musicians, artists are intimidated into voluntary censorship,” she wrote. Her replacement for the concerts is Canadian pianist Stewart Goodyear.
“As one of Canada’s most important cultural institutions,” Mr. Melanson’s statement says, “our priority must remain on being a stage for the world’s great works of music, and not for opinions that some believe to be deeply offensive.”
Note by New Cold War.org editors: Those who follow the news of the considerable influence of the Ukrainian extreme-right in the Parliament of Canada and in Canadian media will not be surprised that the Toronto Symphony Orchestra has bowed to pressure that it ban a internationally-renowned musician for expressing antiwar views. The Globe and Mail, which reported the story on April 6, has a torrent of comments (568-latest count) on its website, near-to universal in condemning the decision of the Toronto Symphony Orchestra. Canada’s state broadcaster, CBC, headquartered in Toronto, has restricted its coverage of this story to a brief news wireservice story posted on its website.
Valentina Lisitsa speaks: Read Valentina Lisitsa’s lengthy Facebook comment on her concert banning by the Toronto Symphony Orchestra here. Valentina Lisitsa was born in Ukraine in 1973 and studied music there. She moved to the United States in 1991.
TSO yanks Ukrainian-born pianist’s shows after talk of ‘deeply offensive’ comments, Toronto Star, April 7, 2015
TSO dumps upcoming soloist Valentina Lisitsa over political views, Musical Toronto, April 6, 2015
Canada’s political mainstream backs war in Ukraine and threats against Russia, by Roger Annis, New Cold War.org, March 31, 2015
EDITOR’S NOTE: We remind our readers that publication of articles on our site does not mean that we agree with what is written. Our policy is to publish anything which we consider of interest, so as to assist our readers in forming their opinions. Sometimes we even publish articles with which we totally disagree, since we believe it is important for our readers to be informed on as wide a spectrum of views as possible.